Retraction

Direct imaging discovery of a Jovian exoplanet within a triple-star system

Paper Information

Record ID:
36523
Author(s):
Kevin Wagner
Daniel Apai
Markus Kasper
Kaitlin Kratter
Melissa McClure
Massimo Robberto
Jean Luc Beuzit
Journal:
Science ( American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) )
Publication Date:
July 07, 2016
Retraction Date:
April 14, 2022 (3.6 years years ago)
Subject:
Broad Categories:
Cosmology
Specific Fields:
Cosmology
Institutions:
Countries:
🇫🇷 France 🇩🇪 Germany 🇺🇸 United States
Article Type:
Research Article
Publisher:
American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS)
Open Access:
Yes
DOI:
10.1126/science.aaf9671
PubMed ID:
27386921
Retraction PubMed ID:
35420970

Retraction Details

Retraction Reasons:
Nature of Retraction:

Retraction

Retraction Notice:
10.1126/science.abq1709

Citations (101)

101
Total Citations
11
Post-Retraction
(10.9%)
89
Pre-Retraction
1
Same Day
Post-Retraction Citation Analysis
1 Within 30 days
5 Within 1 year
2 After 2+ years
1083 Days since retraction (latest)
High-contrast imaging of tight resolved binaries with two vector vortex coronagraphs in cascade with the Palomar SDC instrument
Jonas Kühn, S. Daemgen, Ji Wang et al. (9 authors)
Unknown Journal
Published: Aug 2018
1352 days before retraction
High-contrast imaging of tight resolved binaries with two vector vortex coronagraphs in cascade with the Palomar SDC instrument
Jonas Kühn, S. Daemgen, Ji Wang et al. (9 authors)
Ground-based and Airborne Instrumentation for Astronomy VII Open Access
Published: Jul 2018
6 citations
1357 days before retraction
Experimental test of a 40 cm-long R=100 000 spectrometer for exoplanet characterisation
Guillaume Bourdarot, Étienne Le Coärer, David Mouillet et al. (15 authors)
Ground-based and Airborne Instrumentation for Astronomy VII Open Access
Published: Jul 2018
10 citations
1378 days before retraction
Exoplanet detection in angular differential imaging by statistical learning of the nonstationary patch covariances
Olivier Flasseur, Laurent Denis, Éric Thiébaut et al. (4 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Apr 2018
56 citations
1463 days before retraction
Investigating the young solar system analog HD 95086
G. Chauvin, R. Gratton, M. Bonnefoy et al. (59 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Apr 2018
47 citations
1471 days before retraction
The Orbit of the Companion to HD 100453A: Binary-driven Spiral Arms in a Protoplanetary Disk
Kevin Wagner, Ruobing Dong, Patrick Sheehan et al. (12 authors)
The Astrophysical Journal Open Access
Published: Feb 2018
70 citations
1514 days before retraction
High-charge and multiple-star vortex coronagraphy from stacked vector vortex phase masks
Artur Aleksanyan, Etienne Brasselet
Optics Letters Open Access
Published: Jan 2018
8 citations
1549 days before retraction
On-sky Closed-loop Correction of Atmospheric Dispersion for High-contrast Coronagraphy and Astrometry
Prashant Pathak, Olivier Guyon, Nemanja Jovanović et al. (9 authors)
Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific Open Access
Published: Jan 2018
3 citations
1550 days before retraction
Occurrence Rates from Direct Imaging Surveys
Brendan P. Bowler, E. Nielsen
Springer eBooks
Published: Jan 2018
4 citations
1564 days before retraction
Populations of Planets in Multiple Star Systems
David V. Martin
Springer eBooks
Published: Jan 2018
28 citations
1564 days before retraction
Brown Dwarfs and Free-Floating Planets in Young Stellar Clusters
V. J. S. Béjar, E. L. Martı́n
Springer eBooks
Published: Jan 2018
2 citations
1564 days before retraction
Populations of Planets in Multiple Star Systems
David V. Martin
Springer eBooks
Published: Jan 2018
22 citations
1564 days before retraction
Brown Dwarfs and Free-Floating Planets in Young Stellar Clusters
V. J. S. Béjar, E. L. Martı́n
Springer eBooks
Published: Jan 2018
3 citations
1564 days before retraction
Discovery of a stellar companion to HD 131399A
A. M. Lagrange, M. Keppler, H. Beust et al. (8 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Nov 2017
4 citations
1604 days before retraction
Evidence That the Directly Imaged Planet HD 131399 Ab Is a Background Star
E. Nielsen, Robert J. De Rosa, Julien Rameau et al. (58 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Nov 2017
63 citations
1619 days before retraction
PSYM-WIDE: A Survey for Large-separation Planetary-mass Companions to Late Spectral Type Members of Young Moving Groups
Marie-Ève Naud, Étienne Artigau, René Doyon et al. (8 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Sep 2017
16 citations
1686 days before retraction
PeX 1. Multispectral expansion of residual speckles for planet detection
Nicholas Devaney, Éric Thiébaut
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Open Access
Published: Aug 2017
27 citations
1689 days before retraction
New Orbits Based on Speckle Interferometry at SOAR. II.*
Andreï Tokovinin
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Aug 2017
29 citations
1694 days before retraction
Zones, spots, and planetary-scale waves beating in brown dwarf atmospheres
Dániel Apai, Theodora Karalidi, Mark S. Marley et al. (12 authors)
Science Open Access
Published: Aug 2017
97 citations
1701 days before retraction
Formation of Wide-orbit Gas Giants Near the Stability Limit in Multi-stellar Systems
Arika Higuchi, Shigeru Ida
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Aug 2017
23 citations
1708 days before retraction
Orbiting a binary
M. Bonavita, V. D’Orazi, D. Mesa et al. (56 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Aug 2017
12 citations
1709 days before retraction
Candidate exoplanet host HD 131399A: a nascent Am star
N. Przybilla, P. Aschenbrenner, Sven Buder
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Jul 2017
25 citations
1725 days before retraction
Multiple Disk Gaps and Rings Generated by a Single Super-Earth
Ruobing Dong, Shengtai Li, Eugene Chiang et al. (4 authors)
The Astrophysical Journal Open Access
Published: Jul 2017
178 citations
1739 days before retraction
Implementing focal-plane phase masks optimized for real telescope apertures with SLM-based digital adaptive coronagraphy
Jonas Kühn, Polychronis Patapis, Garreth Ruane et al. (4 authors)
Optics Express Open Access
Published: Jul 2017
7 citations
1743 days before retraction
Characterizing 51 Eri b from 1 to 5 μm: A Partly Cloudy Exoplanet
Abhijith Rajan, Julien Rameau, Robert J. De Rosa et al. (61 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Jun 2017
135 citations
1763 days before retraction
Multiple-Star System Adaptive Vortex Coronagraphy Using a Liquid Crystal Light Valve
Artur Aleksanyan, Nina Kravets, Etienne Brasselet
Physical Review Letters Open Access
Published: May 2017
76 citations
1794 days before retraction
No Difference in Orbital Parameters of RV-detected Giant Planets between 0.1 and 5 au in Single versus Multi-stellar Systems
Henry Ngo, Heather A. Knutson, Marta L. Bryan et al. (11 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: May 2017
49 citations
1806 days before retraction
Spectral and atmospheric characterization of 51 Eridani b using VLT/SPHERE
M. Samland, P. Mollière, M. Bonnefoy et al. (46 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Apr 2017
134 citations
1814 days before retraction
Observing Exoplanets with High Dispersion Coronagraphy. I. The Scientific Potential of Current and Next-generation Large Ground and Space Telescopes
Ji Wang, Dimitri Mawet, Garreth Ruane et al. (5 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Mar 2017
93 citations
1841 days before retraction
1–2.4 μm Near-IR Spectrum of the Giant Planet β Pictoris b Obtained with the Gemini Planet Imager
Jeffrey Chilcote, Laurent Pueyo, Robert J. De Rosa et al. (64 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Mar 2017
112 citations
1843 days before retraction
The VLT/NaCo large program to probe the occurrence of exoplanets and brown dwarfs at wide orbits
A. Vigan, M. Bonavita, Beth Biller et al. (37 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Mar 2017
107 citations
1855 days before retraction
Mid-infrared characterization of the planetary-mass companion ROXs 42B b
S. Daemgen, Kamen Todorov, Jasmin Silva et al. (13 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Mar 2017
7 citations
1865 days before retraction
Sulfur Hazes in Giant Exoplanet Atmospheres: Impacts on Reflected Light Spectra
Peter Gao, Mark S. Marley, Kevin Zahnle et al. (5 authors)
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Mar 2017
82 citations
1870 days before retraction
Effects of Latent Heating on Atmospheres of Brown Dwarfs and Directly Imaged Planets
Xianyu Tan, Adam P. Showman
The Astrophysical Journal Open Access
Published: Jan 2017
30 citations
1900 days before retraction
THE EVOLUTION OF GAS GIANT ENTROPY DURING FORMATION BY RUNAWAY ACCRETION
David Berardo, A. Cumming, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau
The Astrophysical Journal Open Access
Published: Jan 2017
58 citations
1920 days before retraction
The time domain for brown dwarfs and directly imaged giant exoplanets: the power of variability monitoring
Beth Biller
Astronomical Review Open Access
Published: Jan 2017
50 citations
1928 days before retraction
Constraints from Planets in Binaries
Kaitlin M. Kratter
Astrophysics and space science library
Published: Jan 2017
5 citations
1929 days before retraction
Orbiting a binary. SPHERE characterisation of the HD 284149 system
M. Bonavita, V. D’Orazi, D. Mesa et al. (55 authors)
HAL (Le Centre pour la Communication Scientifique Directe) Open Access
Published: Jan 2017
9 citations
1929 days before retraction
THE MEASUREMENT, TREATMENT, AND IMPACT OF SPECTRAL COVARIANCE AND BAYESIAN PRIORS IN INTEGRAL-FIELD SPECTROSCOPY OF EXOPLANETS
Johnny P. Greco, Timothy D. Brandt
The Astrophysical Journal Open Access
Published: Dec 2016
29 citations
1948 days before retraction
PHASE QUANTIZATION STUDY OF SPATIAL LIGHT MODULATOR FOR EXTREME HIGH-CONTRAST IMAGING
Jiangpei Dou, Deqing Ren
The Astrophysical Journal Open Access
Published: Nov 2016
4 citations
1973 days before retraction
A High-precision Technique to Correct for Residual Atmospheric Dispersion in High-contrast Imaging Systems
Prashant Pathak, Olivier Guyon, Nemanja Jovanović et al. (10 authors)
Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific Open Access
Published: Nov 2016
12 citations
1983 days before retraction
Shadows and spirals in the protoplanetary disk HD 100453
M. Benisty, T. Stolker, A. Pohl et al. (49 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Nov 2016
132 citations
1984 days before retraction
The unstable fate of the planet orbiting the A star in the HD 131399 triple stellar system
Dimitri Veras, Alexander J. Mustill, B. T. Gänsicke
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society Open Access
Published: Nov 2016
33 citations
1989 days before retraction
NEW ORBITS BASED ON SPECKLE INTERFEROMETRY AT SOAR<sup>∗</sup>
Andreï Tokovinin
The Astronomical Journal Open Access
Published: Oct 2016
24 citations
1998 days before retraction
Direct detection of scattered light gaps in the transitional disk around HD 97048 with VLT/SPHERE
C. Ginski, T. Stolker, Paola Pinilla et al. (31 authors)
Astronomy and Astrophysics Open Access
Published: Oct 2016
75 citations
2019 days before retraction
CLOUD ATLAS: DISCOVERY OF PATCHY CLOUDS AND HIGH-AMPLITUDE ROTATIONAL MODULATIONS IN A YOUNG, EXTREMELY RED L-TYPE BROWN DWARF
Ben W. P. Lew, Dániel Apai, Yifan Zhou et al. (13 authors)
The Astrophysical Journal Letters Open Access
Published: Sep 2016
67 citations
2023 days before retraction
Making sense of the exoplanet zoo
Rebecca Oppenheimer
Science
Published: Aug 2016
1 citation
2072 days before retraction
The path to visible extreme adaptive optics with MagAO-2K and MagAO-X
Jared R. Males, Laird M. Close, Olivier Guyon et al. (20 authors)
Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE Open Access
Published: Jul 2016
12 citations
2087 days before retraction
SAXO, the SPHERE extreme AO system: on-sky final performance and future improvements
Thierry Fusco, Jean-François Sauvage, D. Mouillet et al. (22 authors)
Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE Open Access
Published: Jul 2016
33 citations
2088 days before retraction
Digital adaptive coronagraphy using SLMs: promising prospects of a novel approach, including high-contrast imaging of multiple stars systems
Jonas Kühn, Polychronis Patapis
Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE
Published: Jul 2016
19 citations
2092 days before retraction
Quick Stats
Total Citations: 101
Years Since Retraction: 3.6 years
Open Access: Yes
Last Checked: Jul 24, 2025
Related Papers
A Bacterium That Can Grow by Using Arsenic Instead of Phosp…
Science • 389 citations
Mitosis Inhibits DNA Double-Strand Break Repair to Guard Ag…
Science • 317 citations
Orchestration of the DNA-Damage Response by the RNF8 Ubiqui…
Science • 887 citations
Mitosis Inhibits DNA Double-Strand Break Repair to Guard Ag…
Science • 317 citations
A room-temperature single-photon source based on strongly i…
Science • 162 citations
Actions
More from this journal Similar subjects View Original Paper View Retraction Notice