Expression of concern
A Global Meta-Analysis on the Impact of Management Practices on Net Global Warming Potential and Greenhouse Gas Intensity from Cropland Soils
Paper Information
Record ID:
36980
Author(s):
Publication Date:
February 22, 2016
Retraction Date:
May 02, 2022
(3.6 years years ago)
Subject:
Broad Categories:
Climate Change
Climate Change
Specific Fields:
Climate Change
Climate Change
Institutions:
Country:
🇺🇸 United StatesArticle Type:
Publisher:
PLoS
Open Access:
Yes
PubMed ID:
Retraction PubMed ID:
Expression of concern Details
Retraction Reasons:
Nature of Retraction:
Expression of concern
Retraction Notice:
10.1371/journal.pone.0268102Citations (89)
89
Total Citations28
Post-Retraction(31.5%)
60
Pre-Retraction1
Same DayPost-Retraction Citation Analysis
1
Within 30 days
10
Within 1 year
11
After 2+ years
1132
Days since retraction (latest)
Earthworm activity increases soil greenhouse gas emission and microbial biomass: a global meta-analysis
Yiqing Wang, Yuchen Zheng, Josep Peñuelas et al. (13 authors)
Plant and Soil
Published: Jun 2025
1132 days after retraction
Straw incorporation mitigates methane emissions by facilitating the conversion of particulate organic carbon to mineral-associated organic carbon
Jiayu Qin, Xinlu Long, Yuxi Zhou et al. (5 authors)
Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment
Published: Jun 2025
1130 days after retraction
Optimizing plant density and nitrogen fertilization in jujube/cotton intercropping systems for sustainable yield and reduced greenhouse gas emissions
Nan Cao, Guodong Chen, Shuang Wang et al. (7 authors)
Field Crops Research
Published: Mar 2025
1059 days after retraction
Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Yield of Durum Wheat Under Organic and Conventional Fertilization in Three Texture Classes
Lucia Ottaiano, Ida Di Mola, Luca Vitale et al. (7 authors)
Agronomy
Open Access
Published: Mar 2025
1046 days after retraction
On-farm carbon capturing strategies to reduce carbon footprint
Rolf Gaël Mabicka Obame, Neil-Yohan Musadji, Rachelle Ntoma Obone et al. (6 authors)
Elsevier eBooks
Published: Jan 2025
975 days after retraction
Mitigation Strategies for NH₃ and N₂O Emissions in Greenhouse Agriculture: Insights into Fertilizer Management and Nitrogen Emission Mechanisms
Xiaorong Luo, Min Zhang, Yuanzhi Ni et al. (4 authors)
Environmental Technology & Innovation
Open Access
Published: Dec 2024
967 days after retraction
Effect of forage alternatives on the carbon footprint, productivity, and profitability of sheep production systems in dryland Mediterranean zone of Chile: A simulation model
Paula Toro-Mújica, Antón García
Ecological Modelling
Published: Dec 2024
1 citation
1 citation
945 days after retraction
Perennial Forage Systems Enhance Ecosystem Quality Variables Compared with Annual Forage Systems
Ogechukwu Igboke, E. S. O. Bortolon, Amanda J. Ashworth et al. (6 authors)
Sustainability
Open Access
Published: Nov 2024
934 days after retraction
Conventional agriculture increases global warming while decreasing system sustainability
Ahmed I. Abdo, Daolin Sun, Zhaoji Shi et al. (6 authors)
Nature Climate Change
Published: Nov 2024
10 citations
10 citations
917 days after retraction
Greenhouse gas emissions in response to tillage, nitrogen fertilization, and manure application in the tropics
S.Y. Alasinrin, F. K. Salako, Mutiu Abolanle Busari et al. (6 authors)
Soil and Tillage Research
Published: Sep 2024
4 citations
4 citations
865 days after retraction
Carbon footprint of global rice production and consumption
Ahmed I. Abdo, Mengzhen Tian, Zhaoji Shi et al. (8 authors)
Journal of Cleaner Production
Published: Sep 2024
3 citations
3 citations
855 days after retraction
Assessing uncertainties and discrepancies in agricultural greenhouse gas emissions estimation in China: A comprehensive review
Hanbing Li, Xiaobin Jin, Rongqin Zhao et al. (6 authors)
Environmental Impact Assessment Review
Open Access
Published: Mar 2024
11 citations
11 citations
694 days after retraction
A global meta‐analysis of yield‐scaled <scp>N<sub>2</sub>O</scp> emissions and its mitigation efforts for maize, wheat, and rice
Zhisheng Yao, Haojie Guo, Yan Wang et al. (8 authors)
Global Change Biology
Published: Feb 2024
31 citations
31 citations
640 days after retraction
Effects of tillage practices on environment, energy, and economy of maize production in Northeast China
Yang Zhang, Zhang Yan, Yan Gao et al. (9 authors)
Agricultural Systems
Published: Jan 2024
5 citations
5 citations
637 days after retraction
Carbon Sequestration and Climate Change Mitigation
Mohammed Zia Uddin Kamal, Mahmuda Akter, Bushra Islam Binte et al. (4 authors)
Unknown Journal
Published: Jan 2024
609 days after retraction
Straw management in paddy fields can reduce greenhouse gas emissions: A global meta-analysis
Zijian He, Hongxia Cao, Qi Chen et al. (6 authors)
Field Crops Research
Published: Dec 2023
31 citations
31 citations
586 days after retraction
The impact of organic fertilizer replacement on greenhouse gas emissions and its influencing factors
Zijian He, Bangxin Ding, Shuyao Pei et al. (6 authors)
The Science of The Total Environment
Published: Sep 2023
50 citations
50 citations
497 days after retraction
Biochar use in agriculture as a nature-based solution: factors influencing N>small<>sub<2>/small<>/sub<O emissions in tropical soils
Fernanda Palmeira Gabetto
Unknown Journal
Open Access
Published: Jul 2023
431 days after retraction
Soil and Ocean Carbon Sequestration, Carbon Capture, Utilization, and Storage as Negative Emission Strategies for Global Climate Change
Divya Pant, Kabita Kumari Shah, Sadikshya Sharma et al. (9 authors)
Journal of soil science and plant nutrition
Published: Mar 2023
27 citations
27 citations
332 days after retraction
Evaluation of site position and tillage effects on global warming potential from furrow-irrigated rice in the mid-southern USA
Diego Della Lunga, Kristofor R. Brye, Jordan M. Slayden et al. (4 authors)
Geoderma Regional
Open Access
Published: Mar 2023
6 citations
6 citations
303 days after retraction
Variation in methodology obscures clarity of cropland global warming potential estimates
Mark A. Liebig, Emma Bergh, David W. Archer
Journal of Environmental Quality
Open Access
Published: Feb 2023
8 citations
8 citations
302 days after retraction
Responses of soil CO2 emissions to tillage practices in a wheat maize cropping system: A 4-year field study
Zhaoxin Li, Qiuying Zhang, Li Zhao et al. (11 authors)
Field Crops Research
Published: Feb 2023
8 citations
8 citations
296 days after retraction
Soil Carbon Sequestration Strategies: Application of Biochar an Option to Combat Global Warming
Shweta Yadav, Vikas Sonkar, Sandeep K. Malyan
Environmental contamination remediation and management
Published: Jan 2023
6 citations
6 citations
244 days after retraction
Understanding response of yield-scaled N2O emissions to nitrogen input: Data synthesis and introducing new concepts of background yield-scaled N2O emissions and N2O emission-yield curve
Dong‐Gill Kim, Donna Giltrap, Tek B. Sapkota
Field Crops Research
Published: Nov 2022
15 citations
15 citations
186 days after retraction
Adapted Conservation Agriculture Practices Can Increase Energy Productivity and Lower Yield-Scaled Greenhouse Gas Emissions in Coastal Bangladesh
Timothy J. Krupnik, Md. Khaled Hossain, Jagadish Timsina et al. (12 authors)
Frontiers in Agronomy
Open Access
Published: Jul 2022
8 citations
8 citations
72 days after retraction
Effects of no-tillage on greenhouse gas emissions in maize fields in a semi-humid temperate climate region
Zhaoxin Li, Qiuying Zhang, Li Zhao et al. (12 authors)
Environmental Pollution
Published: Jul 2022
11 citations
11 citations
70 days after retraction
Current status of carbon neutrality in Chinese rice fields (2002–2017) and strategies for its achievement
Jichao Tang, Tianqi Liu, Yang Jiang et al. (9 authors)
The Science of The Total Environment
Published: Jun 2022
13 citations
13 citations
43 days after retraction
Response of soil organic carbon content to crop rotation and its controls: A global synthesis
Xiaotong Liu, Senwen Tan, Xiaojun Song et al. (7 authors)
Agriculture Ecosystems & Environment
Published: May 2022
63 citations
63 citations
15 days after retraction
Expression of Concern: A Global Meta-Analysis on the Impact of Management Practices on Net Global Warming Potential and Greenhouse Gas Intensity from Cropland Soils
Unknown Authors
PLoS ONE
Open Access
Published: May 2022
Same day as retraction
A global meta-analysis of crop yield and agricultural greenhouse gas emissions under nitrogen fertilizer application
Chan Guo, Xufei Liu, Xuefei He
The Science of The Total Environment
Published: Apr 2022
108 citations
108 citations
28 days before retraction
Sustainability of agricultural practices in Germany: a literature review along multiple environmental domains
Marieke Cornelia Baaken
Regional Environmental Change
Open Access
Published: Mar 2022
24 citations
24 citations
54 days before retraction
Carbon sequestration potential, challenges, and strategies towards climate action in smallholder agricultural systems of South Asia
M.L. Jat, Debashis Chakraborty, J. K. Ladha et al. (11 authors)
Crop and Environment
Open Access
Published: Mar 2022
53 citations
53 citations
62 days before retraction
Paper citing A Global Meta-Analysis on the Impact of Management...
Unknown Authors
Unknown Journal
Published: Feb 2022
69 days before retraction
Global cropland could be almost halved: Assessment of land saving potentials under different strategies and implications for agricultural markets
Julia M. Schneider, Florian Zabel, Franziska Schünemann et al. (5 authors)
PLoS ONE
Open Access
Published: Feb 2022
22 citations
22 citations
69 days before retraction
Evaluation of no-tillage impacts on soil respiration by 13C-isotopic signature in North China Plain
Zhaoxin Li, Qiuying Zhang, Yunfeng Qiao et al. (12 authors)
The Science of The Total Environment
Published: Feb 2022
11 citations
11 citations
76 days before retraction
A Review of Crop Husbandry and Soil Management Practices Using Meta-Analysis Studies: Towards Soil-Improving Cropping Systems
R.P.J.J. Rietra, M. Heinen, O. Oenema
Land
Open Access
Published: Feb 2022
19 citations
19 citations
83 days before retraction
Ecosystem Services from Ecological Agroforestry in Brazil: A Systematic Map of Scientific Evidence
Hanna Ramella Schuler, Gisele Garcia Alarcon, Fernando Joner et al. (6 authors)
Land
Open Access
Published: Jan 2022
24 citations
24 citations
116 days before retraction
Evaluation of Dissolved Greenhouse Gas Profiles in Paddy Fields Irrigated with Treated Sewage Effluent
Shuhei Masuda, Fumiaki Takakai, Kunihiro Okano et al. (7 authors)
Journal of Water and Environment Technology
Open Access
Published: Jan 2022
1 citation
1 citation
121 days before retraction
Assessment of nutrient management in major cereals: Yield prediction, energy-use efficiency and greenhouse gas emission
Jagadish Timsina, Sudarshan Dutta, Krishna Prasad Devkota et al. (8 authors)
Current Research in Environmental Sustainability
Open Access
Published: Jan 2022
15 citations
15 citations
121 days before retraction
Residual nitrogen for succeeding crops in legume-based cropping system
Chetan Kumar Jangir, Anjali Thakur, Hemali Bijani et al. (11 authors)
Elsevier eBooks
Published: Jan 2022
5 citations
5 citations
121 days before retraction
Role of Agricultural Soil Mulching on Net Global Warming Potential and Greenhouse Gas Intensity of Different Cropping Systems
Saadatullah Malghani, Xiaolin Liao
Unknown Journal
Published: Jan 2022
1 citation
1 citation
121 days before retraction
Soil carbon and legumes
Muhammad Imtiaz Rashid, Qaiser Hussain, Rifat Hayat et al. (10 authors)
Elsevier eBooks
Published: Jan 2022
3 citations
3 citations
121 days before retraction
Steering microbiomes by organic amendments towards climate-smart agricultural soils
Kristof Brenzinger, Ohana Y. A. Costa, Adrian Ho et al. (8 authors)
Biology and Fertility of Soils
Open Access
Published: Sep 2021
20 citations
20 citations
219 days before retraction
Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Crop Yields From Winter Oilseed Rape Cropping Systems are Unaffected by Management Practices
M. O’Neill, Gary Lanigan, P.D. Forristal et al. (4 authors)
Frontiers in Environmental Science
Open Access
Published: Sep 2021
10 citations
10 citations
229 days before retraction
Nitrous oxide, methane emissions and grain yield in rainfed wheat grown under nitrogen enriched biochar and straw in a semiarid environment
Stephen Yeboah, Jun Wu, Liqun Cai et al. (6 authors)
PeerJ
Open Access
Published: Aug 2021
6 citations
6 citations
256 days before retraction
Peer Review #2 of "Nitrous oxide, methane emissions and grain yield in rainfed wheat grown under nitrogen enriched biochar and straw in a semiarid environment (v0.1)"
Achouak El Arfaoui
Unknown Journal
Open Access
Published: Aug 2021
256 days before retraction
Peer Review #1 of "Nitrous oxide, methane emissions and grain yield in rainfed wheat grown under nitrogen enriched biochar and straw in a semiarid environment (v0.1)"
Stephen Yeboah, Wu Equal, Liqun Cai et al. (8 authors)
Unknown Journal
Open Access
Published: Aug 2021
256 days before retraction
Peer Review #3 of "Nitrous oxide, methane emissions and grain yield in rainfed wheat grown under nitrogen enriched biochar and straw in a semiarid environment (v0.2)"
Kashif Akhtar
Unknown Journal
Open Access
Published: Aug 2021
256 days before retraction
Peer Review #2 of "Nitrous oxide, methane emissions and grain yield in rainfed wheat grown under nitrogen enriched biochar and straw in a semiarid environment (v0.2)"
Achouak El Arfaoui
Unknown Journal
Open Access
Published: Aug 2021
256 days before retraction
Conservation Agriculture as a System to Enhance Ecosystem Services
Somasundaram Jayaraman, Yash P. Dang, Anandkumar Naorem et al. (5 authors)
Agriculture
Open Access
Published: Jul 2021
43 citations
43 citations
277 days before retraction
Quick Stats
Total Citations:
89
Years Since Retraction:
3.6 years
Open Access:
Yes
Last Checked:
Jul 24, 2025