Retraction
Developing critical thinking skills in a digital educational environment
Paper Information
Record ID:
39630
Journal:
Publication Date:
July 21, 2021
Retraction Date:
December 09, 2022
(2.9 years years ago)
Subjects:
Institutions:
- Department of Foreign Languages # 2, Plekhanov Russian University of Economics, Moscow, Russia
- Foreign Languages Department F-13, Moscow Aviation Institute (National Research University), Moscow, Russia
- Department Information Technologies in the AIC, Russian State Agrarian University - Moscow Timiryazev Agricultural Academy (RSAU – MTAA or RSAU – MAA named after K.A. Timiryazev), Moscow, Russia
- Department of Philosophy and Sociology, Elabuga Institute of Kazan Federal University, Elabuga, Russia
- Department of Theory and Methods of Professional Education, Kazan Federal University, Elabuga, Russia
Country:
🇷🇺 RussiaArticle Type:
Publisher:
Elsevier
Open Access:
Yes
PubMed ID:
Not indexed in PubMed
Retraction PubMed ID:
Not indexed in PubMed
Retraction Details
Retraction Reasons:
Nature of Retraction:
Retraction
Retraction Notice:
10.1016/j.tsc.2022.101088Additional Notes:
html page overwrite
Citations (45)
45
Total Citations31
Post-Retraction(68.9%)
14
Pre-Retraction0
Same DayPost-Retraction Citation Analysis
2
Within 30 days
16
Within 1 year
4
After 2+ years
926
Days since retraction (latest)
Mapping the Evolution of Digital Literacy in Asian Learning Environments: A Bibliometric Analysis
Dek Ngurah Laba Laksana, Dimas Qondias, Kadek Dwi Hendratma Gunawan et al. (6 authors)
Salud Ciencia y Tecnología
Published: Jun 2025
926 days after retraction
Improving Teacher Competence Through Open Inquiry-Based Scientific Investigation Development Training
Abdul Haris, Mahir Mahir
Innovare Journal of Education
Published: May 2025
874 days after retraction
Enhancing Academic Performance Through Self-Explanation in Digital Learning Environments (DLEs): A Three-Level Meta-Analysis
Liping Tan, Shaoying Gong, Yujie Wang et al. (6 authors)
Educational Psychology Review
Published: Mar 2025
1 citation
1 citation
813 days after retraction
Sculpting critical thinkers: A reflection on teaching policy analysis in a South African university
Sibongile Ruth Nhari, Thokozani Ian Nzimakwe
Teaching Public Administration
Published: Dec 2024
738 days after retraction
Enhancing Education Quality: The Transformative Role of ICT in Modern Teaching and Learning
R. Kannan, Jothye Akila, Elenna Elenche Zhia
Advances Educational Innovation.
Published: Nov 2024
693 days after retraction
Standardization in Digital Teaching and Learning in Higher Education: Indonesia Evidence
Andi Kristanto, Siti Aisyah, Farida Febrianti et al. (8 authors)
Journal of Education Technology
Open Access
Published: Jul 2024
2 citations
2 citations
585 days after retraction
A RESEARCH CONDUCTED IN A DEVELOPING NATION STUDIED THE SATISFACTION LEVELS BETWEEN STUDENTS AND TEACHERS AT A PUBLIC UNIVERSITY.
Monika Watts, G. S. Bhalla
ShodhKosh Journal of Visual and Performing Arts
Published: Jun 2024
569 days after retraction
Strengthening the critical thinking skill through the six-hat thinking model in pancasila education
Linda Oktaviani, Ullu Yandi Aulia, Mukhamad Murdiono et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Education and Learning (EduLearn)
Open Access
Published: May 2024
2 citations
2 citations
525 days after retraction
The relation between lateral thinking and inquiry skills of higher education students: A path analysis
Burcu Duman, Emrullah Yılmaz, Ayşegül Tural et al. (4 authors)
European Journal of Education
Open Access
Published: May 2024
1 citation
1 citation
518 days after retraction
Pensamiento crítico en estudiantes de educación básica regular
Liliana Saavedra-Pizarro
Horizontes Revista de Investigación en Ciencias de la Educación
Open Access
Published: Apr 2024
480 days after retraction
The critical thinking research trend in Indonesia’s language education journals
Muhammad Zikrullah, Azhari Azhari
Diksi
Open Access
Published: Mar 2024
478 days after retraction
Critical thinking in higher education: a bibliometric analysis
Ita Nuryana, Bambang Sugeng, Etty Soesilowati et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Applied Research in Higher Education
Published: Feb 2024
3 citations
3 citations
432 days after retraction
Critical Thinking Skills Integrated in English Language Materials in Vocational School
Unknown Authors
Nusantara Science and Technology Proceedings
Open Access
Published: Jan 2024
399 days after retraction
Online learning environments for transferable skills development: a systematic literature review from 2013–2022
Cathy Weng, Kifle Kassaw, Melese Astatke et al. (4 authors)
Interactive Learning Environments
Published: Jan 2024
2 citations
2 citations
389 days after retraction
Embarking on an Action Plan: Proposing Vark Test as the Need Analysis for Classroom Teaching and Learning
Norhamizah Tamat, Noorulziwaty Kamaruzaman, Ezatul Marini Mohd Ghazali
JPI (Jurnal Pendidikan Indonesia)
Open Access
Published: Dec 2023
1 citation
1 citation
379 days after retraction
University learning style model: Bibliometrics and systematic literature review
Laberiano Andrade-Arenas, María Mini Martin Bogdanovich, Domingo Hernández Celis et al. (5 authors)
International Journal of Evaluation and Research in Education (IJERE)
Open Access
Published: Oct 2023
1 citation
1 citation
325 days after retraction
Digital Literacy in Learning Media in the Vocational Education of Serving Dishes
Yeni Yulianti, Annis Kandriasari, Guspri Devi Artanti et al. (4 authors)
JPI (Jurnal Pendidikan Indonesia)
Open Access
Published: Oct 2023
1 citation
1 citation
301 days after retraction
Influence of Work Motivation, Interpersonal Skills, and Knowledge Construction on the Work Readiness of Vocational Students
Cicilia Dyah Sulistyaningrum Indrawati, Anton Subarno, Winarno Winarno et al. (6 authors)
Education Research International
Open Access
Published: Aug 2023
5 citations
5 citations
262 days after retraction
Audio-visual-based history learning media materials about human life in the literary age
Marzius Insani, Een Yayah Haenilah, Hasan Hariri et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Education and Learning (EduLearn)
Open Access
Published: Jul 2023
1 citation
1 citation
234 days after retraction
Profile of Critical Thinking Results Analyzed from Facione Indicators and Gender of Learners
Rima Arini, Yuni Sri Rahayu, Erman Erman
IJORER International Journal of Recent Educational Research
Open Access
Published: Jul 2023
9 citations
9 citations
210 days after retraction
Digital Mapping as a Tool for the Development of Critical Thinking Skills in Digital Education
Karima Sayari
Advances in educational technologies and instructional design book series
Published: Jun 2023
1 citation
1 citation
203 days after retraction
Analysis of critical thinking skills, cognitive learning outcomes, and student activities in learning the human excretory system using an interactive flipbook
Novita Hawsari Aswanti, Wiwi Isnaeni
REID (Research and Evaluation in Education)
Open Access
Published: Jun 2023
10 citations
10 citations
203 days after retraction
Augmented reality technology in enhancing learning retention and critical thinking according to STEAM program
Yaser A. Alkhabra, Usama M. Ibrahem, Saleh Abdullah Alkhabra
Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
Open Access
Published: Apr 2023
43 citations
43 citations
133 days after retraction
Instilling Nationalism Values Through History Learning for Grade XI Students
Rahmadiah Suciati, Dyah Kumalasari, Johan Setiawan
JPI (Jurnal Pendidikan Indonesia)
Open Access
Published: Mar 2023
8 citations
8 citations
111 days after retraction
Audio Visual Based Learning Media in Learning the History of Human Life in the Pre-literacy Age in Indonesia
Nurul Reza Pertiwi, Dyah Kumalasari, Johan Setiawan
JPI (Jurnal Pendidikan Indonesia)
Open Access
Published: Mar 2023
3 citations
3 citations
111 days after retraction
21st Century Skills and Information Literacy in Indonesian Language and Literature Education Study Program
Ni Putu Parmini, Ida Bagus Rai Putra, Mukhamdanah Mukhamdanah et al. (5 authors)
Mimbar Ilmu
Open Access
Published: Mar 2023
10 citations
10 citations
92 days after retraction
Critical thinking skills of Chemistry students by integrating design thinking with STEAM-PjBL
Lintang Rizkyta Ananda, Yuli Rahmawati, Fauzan Khairi
Journal of Technology and Science Education
Open Access
Published: Feb 2023
19 citations
19 citations
61 days after retraction
Hubungan Sistem Reward dan Punishment Pada Sikap Disiplin Mata Pelajaran Sejarah
Anny Wahyuni, Melita Anggriani Situmorang, Yundi Fitrah
ULUL ALBAB Jurnal Studi Islam
Open Access
Published: Feb 2023
57 days after retraction
Learning History in Facing the Era of Society 5.0
Sumiyatun Sumiyatun, Elis Setiawati
IARJSET
Open Access
Published: Jan 2023
42 days after retraction
Self-Assessment Instrument Online Opportunity Skills and Online Risk Survival Skills for e-Learning Students of Economics and Education Programs
Hery Sawiji, Dede Rusmana, Sigit Permansah et al. (8 authors)
Advances in economics, business and management research/Advances in Economics, Business and Management Research
Open Access
Published: Jan 2023
23 days after retraction
Desarrollo de habilidades del pensamiento crítico en educación universitaria: Una revisión sistemática
Liliana Pedraja-Rejas, Carlos Cisterna
Revista de ciencias sociales.
Open Access
Published: Jan 2023
2 citations
2 citations
23 days after retraction
Distance learning of a foreign language at a technical university
Darya Kapustina, Anna Zakharova, Leyla Goyushova
Revista on line de Política e Gestão Educacional
Open Access
Published: Nov 2022
1 citation
1 citation
29 days before retraction
The impact of attitude toward peer interaction on middle school students' problem-solving self-efficacy during the COVID-19 pandemic
Xin An, Jon‐Chao Hong, Yushun Li et al. (4 authors)
Frontiers in Psychology
Open Access
Published: Aug 2022
8 citations
8 citations
106 days before retraction
The link between English foreign language teacher’s professional identity and their critical thinking that leads to teacher’s success in the Chinese context: Leaders motivational language as a moderator
Fangfang Ding, Xingyu Liu, Alaa Amin Abdalla et al. (5 authors)
Frontiers in Psychology
Open Access
Published: Aug 2022
3 citations
3 citations
119 days before retraction
Enhancing students critical thinking skills in writing by promoting ESP-based language learning environment
Pg Ahmad Hasanuddin, Zamrin Md Zin, Noor Azlin Yamin et al. (4 authors)
International Journal of Health Sciences
Open Access
Published: Jul 2022
149 days before retraction
Enhancing students critical thinking skills in writing by promoting ESP-based language learning environment
Pg Ahmad Hasanuddin, Zamrin Md Zin, Noor Azlin Yamin et al. (8 authors)
International Journal of Health Sciences
Open Access
Published: May 2022
4 citations
4 citations
192 days before retraction
Mobile learning application: Infusing critical thinking in the EFL classroom.
Noni Agustina, Ilza Mayuni, Ifan Iskandar et al. (4 authors)
Deleted Journal
Open Access
Published: May 2022
16 citations
16 citations
200 days before retraction
Adoption of M-Learning in Business English Course and Its Relationship to Learning Style Preferences: An Empirical Investigation
Xiaojun Cao
Frontiers in Psychology
Open Access
Published: May 2022
5 citations
5 citations
219 days before retraction
Critical Pedagogy through Genre-Based Pedagogy for Developing Students' Writing Skills: Strategies and Challenges
Uswatun Qoyyimah, Yosi Agustiawan, Thanh Thao Phan et al. (5 authors)
NOBEL Journal of Literature and Language Teaching
Open Access
Published: Apr 2022
4 citations
4 citations
223 days before retraction
Effectiveness of Students' Motivation Factors in the Competency-Based Approach: A Case Study of Universities in Russia and Indonesia
Nuphanudin Nuphanudin, Aan Komariah, Tatiana V. Shvetsova et al. (10 authors)
Emerging Science Journal
Open Access
Published: Apr 2022
10 citations
10 citations
234 days before retraction
Synchronous Online Learning in Higher Education: Vietnamese University Students’ Perspectives
Ngoc Tung Vu, Minh Hai Nguyen Tran
Journal of Ethnic and Cultural Studies
Open Access
Published: Feb 2022
3 citations
3 citations
287 days before retraction
Development of Ispring Interactive Powerpoint Media in Photosynthesis Topic to Train Critical Thinking Skills
Aulia Dhita Nanda, Yuliani Yuliani
Berkala Ilmiah Pendidikan Biologi (BioEdu)
Open Access
Published: Feb 2022
301 days before retraction
Analysis of approaches to evaluate the quality of distant educational services
Anastasia D. Kolbina, Natalya Yu. Chetyrkina, Maria Nizamieva
AIP conference proceedings
Open Access
Published: Jan 2022
1 citation
1 citation
342 days before retraction
RETRACTED: Creative thinking and musical collaboration: Promoting online learning groups for aspiring musicians
Meng Zhang, Minjian Guo, Banghan Xiao
Thinking Skills and Creativity
Published: Sep 2021
16 citations
16 citations
453 days before retraction
RETRACTED: The role of mobile web platforms in the development of critical, strategic and lateral thinking skills of students in distance physical education courses
Yue Qi
Thinking Skills and Creativity
Published: Aug 2021
11 citations
11 citations
469 days before retraction
Quick Stats
Total Citations:
45
Years Since Retraction:
2.9 years
Open Access:
Yes
Last Checked:
Jul 24, 2025