Retraction
Congruence and discrepancy between working alliance and real relationship: Variance decomposition and response surface analyses
Paper Information
Record ID:
45894
Publication Date:
April 06, 2017
Retraction Date:
July 01, 2023
(2.4 years years ago)
Subjects:
Institutions:
Country:
đșđž United StatesArticle Type:
Publisher:
American Psychological Association (APA)
Open Access:
Yes
DOI:
PubMed ID:
Retraction PubMed ID:
Retraction Details
Retraction Reasons:
Nature of Retraction:
Retraction
Retraction Notice:
10.1037/cou0000675Additional Notes:
see also: https://www.spectrumnews.org/news/exclusive-investigation-prompts-retraction-of-17-studies-from-now-shuttered-clinic/?utm_source=Spectrum+Newsletters&utm_campaign=a4cfd95c13-NEWS+ALERT+20230714+PSYCH+RETRACTIONS&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_529db1161f-a4cfd95c13-169124514
Citations (28)
28
Total Citations3
Post-Retraction(10.7%)
25
Pre-Retraction0
Same DayPost-Retraction Citation Analysis
1
Within 30 days
2
Within 1 year
0
After 2+ years
382
Days since retraction (latest)
How Parental Mediation and Parental Phubbing Affect Preschool Childrenâs Screen Media Use: A Response Surface Analysis
Jia Wang, RuâDe Liu, Yi Ding et al. (5 authors)
Cyberpsychology Behavior and Social Networking
Published: Jul 2024
4 citations
4 citations
382 days after retraction
The assessment of therapist responsiveness in psychotherapy research: a systematic review
Giovanna Esposito, Francesco Cuomo, Angela Di Maro et al. (4 authors)
Research in Psychotherapy Psychopathology Process and Outcome
Open Access
Published: Jun 2024
2 citations
2 citations
354 days after retraction
The real relationship: the Portuguese version of the <em>Real Relationship Inventory-Client</em> form
Pedro Rodrigues Ribeiro, David Dias Neto
Research in Psychotherapy Psychopathology Process and Outcome
Open Access
Published: Jul 2023
1 citation
1 citation
4 days after retraction
The sister concepts of working alliance and real relationship: A meta-analysis
Ana Marta Vaz, Laura InĂȘs Ferreira, Charles J. Gelso et al. (4 authors)
Counselling Psychology Quarterly
Open Access
Published: Apr 2023
17 citations
17 citations
69 days before retraction
Exclusive: Investigation prompts retraction of 17 studies from now-shuttered clinic
Calli McMurray
The Transmitter
Open Access
Published: Jan 2023
181 days before retraction
Client-therapist temporal congruence in perceiving immediate therapist self-disclosure and its association with treatment outcome
Tal AlfiâYogev, Yogev Kivity, Ilanit HassonâOhayon et al. (6 authors)
Psychotherapy Research
Published: Dec 2022
3 citations
3 citations
202 days before retraction
Die Arbeitsbeziehung im Coaching: Ein ForschungsĂŒberblick und Handlungsempfehlungen fĂŒr die Praxis
Carolin GraĂmann
Organisationsberatung Supervision Coaching
Open Access
Published: Jul 2022
4 citations
4 citations
346 days before retraction
Relationship and Alliance Formation Processes in Psychotherapy: A Dual-Perspective Qualitative Study
Kristina Osland Lavik, Andrew A. McAleavey, Eli Karoline Kvendseth et al. (4 authors)
Frontiers in Psychology
Open Access
Published: Jul 2022
8 citations
8 citations
359 days before retraction
Patientsâ attachment avoidance and their perceived quality of the real relationship predict patientsâ attitudes towards telepsychotherapy
Vera BĂ©kĂ©s, Katie Aafjesâvan Doorn
Counselling Psychology Quarterly
Published: Jul 2022
6 citations
6 citations
363 days before retraction
The Synergistic but Troubled Relationship Between Psychotherapy Science and Practice: Moving Forward
Charles J. Gelso, Clara E. Hill, Dennis M. Kivlighan
The Counseling Psychologist
Published: Aug 2021
4 citations
4 citations
670 days before retraction
Introducing Social Breathing: A Model of Engaging in Relational Systems
Niclas Kaiser, Emily A. Butler
Frontiers in Psychology
Open Access
Published: Apr 2021
10 citations
10 citations
814 days before retraction
Understanding congruence in person-centred counselling practice: A trainee counsellorâs perspective
Natri Sutanti
ProGCouns Journal of Professionals in Guidance and Counseling
Open Access
Published: Nov 2020
5 citations
5 citations
944 days before retraction
College studentsâ ambivalence over emotional expression and counselorâs directiveness: an analogue experiment on perceived therapeutic bond
Seong-In Choi, Eunha Kim, Sage Comstock et al. (4 authors)
Counselling Psychology Quarterly
Published: Feb 2020
1221 days before retraction
A meta-analysis of client-therapist perspectives on the therapeutic alliance: Examining the moderating role of type of measurement and diagnosis
Libby Igra, Michal Lavidor, Dana AtzilâSlonim et al. (6 authors)
European Psychiatry
Open Access
Published: Jan 2020
12 citations
12 citations
1277 days before retraction
Are high-performing therapists both effective and consistent? A test of therapist expertise.
Jesse Owen, Joanna M. Drinane, D. Martin Kivlighan et al. (6 authors)
Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology
Published: Sep 2019
6 citations
6 citations
1377 days before retraction
The sister concepts of the working alliance and the real relationship: on their development, rupture, and repair
Charles J. Gelso, Kathryn V. Kline
Research in Psychotherapy Psychopathology Process and Outcome
Open Access
Published: Jul 2019
20 citations
20 citations
1432 days before retraction
Is there an optimal level of positive and negative feedback in group therapy? A response surface analysis.
D. Martin Kivlighan, Ramsey W Ali, Yunkyoung Loh Garrison
Psychotherapy
Published: Jul 2019
4 citations
4 citations
1437 days before retraction
Physiological synchrony and therapeutic alliance in an imagery-based treatment.
Eran BarâKalifa, Jessica Prinz, Dana AtzilâSlonim et al. (6 authors)
Journal of Counseling Psychology
Published: May 2019
54 citations
54 citations
1493 days before retraction
The relationship between working alliance and client outcomes in coaching: A meta-analysis
Carolin GraĂmann, Franziska Schölmerich, Carsten C. Schermuly
Human Relations
Published: Feb 2019
142 citations
142 citations
1590 days before retraction
The Therapeutic Alliance Over 10 Sessions of Therapy for Borderline Personality Disorder: Agreement and Congruence Analysis and Relation to Outcome
Yogev Kivity, Kenneth N. Levy, Stéphane Kolly et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Personality Disorders
Open Access
Published: Jan 2019
11 citations
11 citations
1615 days before retraction
Different strokes for different folks: Examining additive and complimentary effects of the advisory working alliance and research team cohesion on traineesâ research outcomes.
D. Martin Kivlighan, Rayna C. Narvaez, Walter Carter
Journal of Counseling Psychology
Published: Nov 2018
5 citations
5 citations
1675 days before retraction
Mutuality in psychotherapy: A meta-analysis and meta-synthesis.
Jeffrey H. D. CorneliusâWhite, Yasuko Kanamori, David Murphy et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Psychotherapy Integration
Open Access
Published: Oct 2018
16 citations
16 citations
1717 days before retraction
The real relationship and its role in psychotherapy outcome: A meta-analysis.
Charles J. Gelso, Dennis M. Kivlighan, Rayna D. Markin
Psychotherapy
Published: Oct 2018
59 citations
59 citations
1717 days before retraction
What happens when the therapist leaves? The impact of therapy transfer on the therapeutic alliance and symptoms
D. Zimmermann, Wolfgang Lutz, Michelle Reiser et al. (8 authors)
Clinical Psychology & Psychotherapy
Open Access
Published: Sep 2018
7 citations
7 citations
1740 days before retraction
Keep calm and alert and carry on: therapist calmness and fatigue in relation to session process
Harold Chui, Clara E. Hill
Counselling Psychology Quarterly
Published: Jul 2018
4 citations
4 citations
1796 days before retraction
Unmet social support needs among college students: Relations between social support discrepancy and depressive and anxiety symptoms.
James A. Rankin, Courtney Paisley, Mazheruddin M. Mulla et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Counseling Psychology
Published: Jul 2018
50 citations
50 citations
1826 days before retraction
The association between patientâtherapist MATRIX congruence and treatment outcome
Shlomo Mendlovic, Amit Saad, Uri Roll et al. (6 authors)
Psychotherapy Research
Published: Mar 2018
2 citations
2 citations
1935 days before retraction
Research on the alliance: Knowledge in search of a theory
Adam O. Horvath
Psychotherapy Research
Open Access
Published: Sep 2017
116 citations
116 citations
2117 days before retraction
Quick Stats
Total Citations:
28
Years Since Retraction:
2.4 years
Open Access:
Yes
Last Checked:
Jul 24, 2025