Retraction

High replicability of newly discovered social-behavioural findings is achievable

Paper Information

Record ID:
57113
Author(s):
John Protzko
Jon Krosnick
Leif Nelson
Brian A Nosek
Jordan Axt
Matt Berent
Nicholas Buttrick
Matthew DeBell
Charles R Ebersole
Sebastian Lundmark
Bo MacInnis
Michael O’Donnell
Hannah Perfecto
James E Pustejovsky
Scott S Roeder
Jan Walleczek
Jonathan W Schooler
Journal:
Nature Human Behaviour ( Springer - Nature Publishing Group )
Publication Date:
November 09, 2023
Retraction Date:
September 24, 2024 (1.2 year years ago)
Subjects:
Broad Categories:
Psychology Sociology Statistics
Institutions:
Countries:
🇨🇦 Canada 🇩🇪 Germany 🇸🇪 Sweden 🇺🇸 United States
Article Type:
Meta-Analysis
Publisher:
Springer - Nature Publishing Group
Open Access:
Yes
DOI:
10.1038/s41562-023-01749-9
PubMed ID:
37945809
Retraction PubMed ID:
39317794

Retraction Details

Retraction Reasons:
Nature of Retraction:

Retraction

Retraction Notice:
10.1038/s41562-024-01997-3
Additional Notes:

see also: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-024-01982-w

Citations (45)

45
Total Citations
15
Post-Retraction
(33.3%)
29
Pre-Retraction
1
Same Day
Post-Retraction Citation Analysis
4 Within 30 days
15 Within 1 year
0 After 2+ years
250 Days since retraction (latest)
Incorporating Quantitative Literacy into a T32 Retreat: Lessons and Considerations from Experience
Anthony Hall, Jenna R McGrath
eNeuro Open Access
Published: Jun 2025
250 days after retraction
Transparency, reproducibility, and replicability in human resource management research
Herman Aguinis, Amando Cope, Ursula M. Martin et al. (4 authors)
Personnel Review Open Access
Published: May 2025
244 days after retraction
A narrative review of the consistency, rigor and generalizability of experiments on prosocial behaviors and happiness
Jason D. E. Proulx, Kristina K. Castaneto, Tiara A. Cash et al. (4 authors)
Discover Psychology Open Access
Published: Mar 2025
160 days after retraction
The Artificial Social Agent Questionnaire (ASAQ) - Development and evaluation of a validated instrument for capturing human interaction experiences with artificial social agents
Siska Fitrianie, Merijn Bruijnes, Amal Abdulrahman et al. (4 authors)
International Journal of Human-Computer Studies
Published: Mar 2025
1 citation
158 days after retraction
Probleme der Erfolgsgeschichte Psychologie
Peter Michael Bak
Springer eBooks
Published: Jan 2025
99 days after retraction
Preregistration and predictivism
Hong Hui Choi
Synthese
Published: Dec 2024
78 days after retraction
Incentives and the Replication Crisis in Social Sciences: A Critical Review of Open Science Practices
Loukas Balafoutas, Jeremy Celse, Alexandros Karakostas et al. (4 authors)
Journal of Behavioral and Experimental Economics
Published: Dec 2024
68 days after retraction
Science as a global public good: A necessary responsibility for science
Geoffrey Boulton
Elsevier eBooks
Published: Nov 2024
66 days after retraction
Glutamate, GABA and NAA in treatment-resistant schizophrenia: a systematic review of the effect of clozapine and group differences between clozapine-responders and non-responders
M. Kristensen, Bahast Biuk, Jimmi Nielsen et al. (5 authors)
Behavioural Brain Research
Published: Nov 2024
1 citation
56 days after retraction
Beyond Eyeball Tests: A Methodical Rebuttal to Fillon et al.'s Commentary
Jaïs Adam‐Troian, Jocelyn J. Bélanger
Aggressive Behavior Open Access
Published: Nov 2024
38 days after retraction
Paper citing High replicability of newly discovered social-beha...
Unknown Authors
Unknown Journal
Published: Oct 2024
35 days after retraction
What meta‐research has taught us about research and changes to research practices
John P. A. Ioannidis
Journal of Economic Surveys Open Access
Published: Oct 2024
8 citations
22 days after retraction
‘Doing good science is hard’: retraction of high-profile reproducibility study prompts soul-searching
Holly Else
Nature
Published: Oct 2024
2 citations
20 days after retraction
Disagreeing to Agree: Problem-Solving and Knowledge Production
Monica Prasad
Organization Theory Open Access
Published: Oct 2024
7 days after retraction
Why are replication rates so low?
Patrick Vu
Journal of Econometrics Open Access
Published: Oct 2024
7 days after retraction
Claims about scientific rigour require rigour
Joseph B. Bak-Coleman, Berna Devezer
Nature Human Behaviour
Published: Sep 2024
9 citations
Same day as retraction
A standardized framework to test event-based experiments
Alex Lepauvre, Rony Hirschhorn, Katarina Bendtz et al. (5 authors)
Behavior Research Methods Open Access
Published: Sep 2024
3 citations
8 days before retraction
Estimating the replicability of highly cited clinical research (2004–2018)
Gabriel Gonçalves da Costa, Kleber Neves, Olavo B. Amaral
PLoS ONE Open Access
Published: Aug 2024
48 days before retraction
The assessment of replicability using the sum of <i>p</i> -values
Leonhard Held, Samuel Pawel, Charlotte Micheloud
Royal Society Open Science Open Access
Published: Aug 2024
3 citations
54 days before retraction
Risky-Choice Framing Effects Result Partly From Mismatched Option Descriptions in Gains and Losses
Michael L. DeKay, Shiyu Dou
Psychological Science Open Access
Published: Jun 2024
98 days before retraction
Metachangemaking: An interdisciplinary synthesis of research on cultivating changemakers
Brandon Reynante, John Wilcox, Oliver L. Stephenson et al. (5 authors)
Journal of Moral Education
Published: Jun 2024
1 citation
113 days before retraction
Inter-Rater Reliability in Assessing the Methodological Quality of Research Papers in Psychology
Franka Tabitha Etzel, Anna Seyffert-Müller, Felix D. Schönbrodt et al. (7 authors)
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: May 2024
2 citations
139 days before retraction
Generalizability and Effectiveness of Choice Architecture Interventions
Barnabás Szászi, Daniel G. Goldstein, Dilip Soman et al. (4 authors)
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: May 2024
2 citations
144 days before retraction
A standardized framework to test event-based experiments
Alex Lepauvre, Rony Hirschhorn, Katarina Bendtz et al. (5 authors)
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: Apr 2024
147 days before retraction
Research Transparency in 59 Disciplines of Clinical Medicine: A Meta-Research Study
Ahmad Sofi‐Mahmudi, Eero Raittio, Sergio Uribe et al. (8 authors)
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: Apr 2024
155 days before retraction
The Replication Database: Documenting the Replicability of Psychological Science
Lukas Röseler, Leonard Kaiser, Christopher Albert Doetsch et al. (97 authors)
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: Apr 2024
4 citations
166 days before retraction
Open Access, Scholarly Communication, and Open Science in Psychology: An Overview for Researchers
Laura Bowering Mullen
SAGE Open Open Access
Published: Apr 2024
3 citations
176 days before retraction
Replication Value: A Comment and Alternative
René Bekkers
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: Mar 2024
181 days before retraction
On the Continued Need for Replication in Media and Communication Research
Nicholas David Bowman
Media and Communication Open Access
Published: Mar 2024
3 citations
187 days before retraction
Decatastrophizing research irreproducibility
Michael F. Jarvis
Biochemical Pharmacology
Published: Feb 2024
3 citations
213 days before retraction
Open science and the climate crisis
Michael Fell, Nicole E. Watson, Gesche Huebner
PLOS Climate Open Access
Published: Feb 2024
230 days before retraction
Interdisciplinary lessons and recommendations for the evaluation of replicability in behavioral sciences
Mitch Brown, Donald F. Sacco
Politics and the Life Sciences Open Access
Published: Jan 2024
267 days before retraction
Advancing the Everyone’s Right to Forest Science: opening research data and computational codes in Silva Fennica
Pekka Nygren
Silva Fennica Open Access
Published: Jan 2024
267 days before retraction
Causal claims about scientific rigor require rigorous causal evidence.
Joseph B. Bak-Coleman, Berna Devezer
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: Nov 2023
1 citation
309 days before retraction
What reproducibility crisis? New research protocol yields ultra-high replication rate
David Adam
Nature
Published: Nov 2023
4 citations
320 days before retraction
What I didn’t grow up with is dangerous: personal experience with a new technology or societal change reduces the belief that it corrupts youth
John Protzko, Jonathan W. Schooler
Frontiers in Psychology Open Access
Published: Oct 2023
2 citations
348 days before retraction
Survey of open science practices and attitudes in the social sciences
Joel Ferguson, Rebecca Littman, Garret Christensen et al. (9 authors)
Nature Communications Open Access
Published: Sep 2023
40 citations
385 days before retraction
Are most published research findings false in a continuous universe?
Kleber Neves, Pedro Batista Tan, Olavo B. Amaral
PLoS ONE Open Access
Published: Dec 2022
2 citations
644 days before retraction
AI and We in the Future in the Light of the Ouroboros Model: A Plea for Plurality
K. Thomsen
AI Open Access
Published: Sep 2022
5 citations
733 days before retraction
Questionable Research Practices, Low Statistical Power, and Other Obstacles to Replicability: Why Preclinical Neuroscience Research Would Benefit from Registered Reports
Randall J. Ellis
eNeuro Open Access
Published: Jul 2022
17 citations
816 days before retraction
Trinity review: integrating Registered Reports with research ethics and funding reviews
Yuki Mori, Kaito Takashima, Kohei Ueda et al. (5 authors)
BMC Research Notes Open Access
Published: May 2022
3 citations
859 days before retraction
Invariance: What Does Measurement Invariance Allow us to Claim?
John Protzko
Unknown Journal Open Access
Published: Apr 2022
5 citations
890 days before retraction
Protecting against researcher bias in secondary data analysis: challenges and potential solutions
Jessie R. Baldwin, Jean‐Baptiste Pingault, Tabea Schoeler et al. (5 authors)
European Journal of Epidemiology Open Access
Published: Jan 2022
103 citations
997 days before retraction
Brain markers predicting response to cognitive‐behavioral therapy for social anxiety disorder: an independent replication of Whitfield-Gabrieli et al. 2015
Yoni K. Ashar, Joseph Clark, Faith M. Gunning et al. (6 authors)
Translational Psychiatry Open Access
Published: May 2021
11 citations
1242 days before retraction
Reducing intrusive memories after trauma via a brief cognitive task intervention in the hospital emergency department: an exploratory pilot randomised controlled trial
Marie Kanstrup, Laura Singh, Katarina E. Göransson et al. (9 authors)
Translational Psychiatry Open Access
Published: Jan 2021
72 citations
1352 days before retraction
Quick Stats
Total Citations: 45
Years Since Retraction: 1.2 year
Open Access: Yes
Last Checked: Jul 24, 2025
Related Papers
Machine learning of neural representations of suicide and e…
Nature Human Behaviour • 215 citations
Actions
More from this journal Similar subjects View Original Paper View Retraction Notice